Pre-trip thoughts

Pre-trip thoughts

[NOTE: On Tuesday, May 16th, a team of three faculty and several FPU students will travel to Israel/Palestine. This is not a typical “Holy Land Tour,” where the purpose is to visit religious/historical sites. This trip is designed to become better acquainted with individuals and groups involved in the various PEACE MOVEMENTS. I’ll write at the end of each day a reflection of that day’s events]

Screen Shot 2017-05-23 at 2.53.57 AM

One of the first lessons we learn in conflict resolution (after our first fight with a sibling, a tussle on the playground) is that there are “two sides to every story,” and that you cannot resolve a conflict until you hear the other person’s side. Obvious, now, correct? Quite a revelation when we first heard it.

In preparation for our trip, our group purposed to understand “both sides of the story” of Israel/Palestine (The first thing we learned was to refer to the geographical area we call “The Holy Land” as “Israel Palestine”). We, collectively, read a book – the Lemon Tree by Sandy Tolan – read articles and watched videos. In addition, I read several other books: My Promised Land by Ari Shavit, Israel/Palestine by Alan Dowty, biographies on some of the key actors (Rabin, Begin, Peres), dozens of YouTube videos, and articles on other key individuals and events.

As we start our journey, I think I know the basics of both sides of the story – just the basics. I know our Biblical account of Isaac and Ishmael and the conflict between the brothers that is one explanation of the current state of things. I know the basics (only the basics) of the major wars, peace accords, economic, political, and geographic issues. I know the basics (just the basics) of the justifications for the perspectives of each side of the story. As we start the trip, this is what I have learned: The Israel/Palestine story is complicated, difficult to learn and almost impossible to understand.

If there are two sides to every story, in Israel/Palestine each side also has two sides (if not three, four, five, etc.); and each of those sides has two sides (if not three, four, five, etc.) and so on, until you get to each individual, and inside of them you’ll find two sides (if not three, four, five, etc.) as they are as often as internally divided as their country.

So, what seems to be the case is that, here, the two sides of the basic story have disintegrated into ever-so-many pieces, a land with as many fragments as their are individuals. In all this, there are brave souls in various peace movements trying to sew together a whole out of the various pieces to bring the various collective and individual stories into a single, redemptive story.

It is these stories I am looking forward to hearing.

Study Abroad
Gary Gramenz

Gary Gramenz

Palestine & Israel Tagged: 2017 Abroad FPU Israel Palestine